Divorce - Any Good News?
Mark 10:2-16 (Pentecost 18a), October 4, 2009
Choices! Sometimes the choices we are called to make are anything but easy. As a male over 50 shall I go for my annual prostate examination or not? As a close friend of someone who is engaging in an activity or activities that are destructive for themself, shall I say or do anything. If I don't say anything they likely will continue in said destructive behavior. If I do say something they may end their friendship with me and continue in their behavior anyway. Or, they may reconsider their course of action and stop it. What shall we do or say? To speak and risk or, not to speak and risk?
The choices and decisions are almost endless. As we get older when do we downsize? When shall we get ourselves assessed in terms of being on a waiting list for enriched housing or a care facility? If we choose to do nothing now, what will happen later?
Many of the choices we make now impact us and others for varying amounts of time.
Pastors must make choices too. Which lesson shall I preach on? Do I preach on Job which raises the entire question of human suffering and the goodness of God, in this particular case the suffering of an absolutely innocent person? Wow – the suffering of innocent people, there's a huge topic! Especially today – the Oregon school shooting, the civil war in Syria, gang warfare in the Lower Mainland.
Or, do I preach on Mark's text where Jesus utters an incredibly difficult statement on divorce?
After a couple of days of reflection I have decided to preach on Mark's Gospel text. I do this because I am convinced that on both immediate and long term levels there is a word, a hopeful word for all of us.
Some would question whether there is any good news here at all. Even if we attempt to do an end run around whatever it is Jesus is saying about divorce and get to the children, we need to realize that about 60% of the children in Jesus' time died before they reached the age of 16. It is distinctly possible that the children brought to Jesus in this text were ill. I say this because the word 'touch' used in the text is only used by Mark in healing accounts. Even the children are sick! Where is the good news in that?
But, before we pass judgment we need to hear the whole story. The Pharisees, were people who were very concerned about the application of religious law in their daily life. By this time in Mark's gospel the Pharisees were on the "outs" with Jesus. They didn't like what he was doing to the status quo of their religion, to their own understanding of family. Now they ask him a question, perhaps hoping that his response will put him in lots of trouble with others, especially those in positions of power.
So they ask, "Is it lawful for a man to divorce his wife?" The intent of their question is this: "Is it more than OK with God, can divorce be blessed by God?"
But Jesus delves far beyond what appears to be the intention of the Pharisees' question. Jesus' response appears to intend that people glimpse God's intention for relationships. God has great hopes for human life!
In this context I tell you a story. The woman is about 30 years old. She has been blessed with 3 children – all under the age of 7. She lives with her husband – a short but very strong man. She wants her baby to be baptized. The Pastor shows up in the early afternoon to talk with her about that. Her husband is gone – not at work, but somewhere. The Pastor meets with her, listens to her share her hopes for her child and a bit about her faith. Still, "something" doesn't feel right. About an hour into the visit, the husband comes home. He has been drinking. He isn't falling down drunk. He is polite. Yet as he enters the room, the entire atmosphere changes. Later the Pastor learns that this man physically beats his wife, verbally berates her and has threatened her with a gun.
What would you do if you were this woman's friend? What would you do if you were her Pastor? Is it lawful, might it even be "good" for this woman to divorce this man?
Into this, our reality, comes Mark's text and Jesus' words. Jesus responds to the question the Pharisees ask. I think that in his response Jesus holds up God's hope, God's intention not only for marriage but even for human relationships in general..
It is also important to note some of the cultural differences between Jesus' time and our time. Then, marriage didn't occur after 2 people had been dating, fallen in love and then made the decision to make incredible promises to each other. No! Then, marriage was a promise entered into by 2 families – sometimes for financial reasons, perhaps even with an eye to keeping the Jewish race alive. Such promises were initiated by the fathers of those families. Fathers were understood to own and control the lives of their wives and their unmarried daughters.
When such promises were broken – and in the Jewish community of Jesus' time they could only be broken by the males – family feuding, shame and dishonor resulted. One of the grounds for divorce was when a marriage did not result in any children. Quite often the woman was blamed. Divorce then may have occurred.
Jesus' concern about all this is not just for the sake of who will own property. Instead, Jesus holds up the intent that no person be discarded whether they "produce" children or not. Nor should anyone be 'discarded' because the man finds some other woman more attractive in some way or even because some woman finds some other man more attractive in some way. Instead it is God's intention that all people be respected, that the promises to love, cherish and respect the marriage partner be honored. When that intention is disregarded and broken, much pain results. Such broken promises result in fractures in interpersonal relationships, families and between people and God.
Don't we ourselves know and experience this? One of the most painful realities that I observe and experience is the reality of divorce. Jesus underlines the truth, the reality of the law. This is not God's intent. We should not do it.
And yet, there is more to it than just Jesus' command, "Don't do it". There is also the fullness of our reality. Don't' we all fall short some regard of God's intent – whether we are married, still married or never been married or are currently divorced? Who among us has not looked at a person besides our spouse with desire? Who among us has not at times been mean or thoughtless towards the one we have promised to love 'til death do us part? We are all guilty – by God's law. We are all in need of forgiveness and new life!
So, where is the good news? Where is the hope in the midst of our reality?
At the end of our lesson, children are brought to Jesus that he might touch them. In Jesus' day children were viewed quite differently than children are now. Then children weren't seen as being sweet, innocent or cute.
Indeed the children that are being brought to Jesus at this point in Mark's Gospel are ill – perhaps smelly, coughing, maybe even suffering from diarrhea. They may have been perceived as being contagiously ill. People may have tried to keep their distance.
Nevertheless, Jesus takes these children in his arms and blesses them. Then Jesus says the most amazing thing: "unless one enters the kingdom of God, the rule and realm of influence of God, like a little child, that person will never enter it."
Here Jesus takes up the vulnerable, the needy, the hurting, the ones that society would distance itself from and blesses them with Himself, His physical touch, His love, His support.
It is precisely in such acts of Jesus that we are encountering hope. Whatever is going on in our lives – especially when our relationships with others are fractured and fracturing, we need Christ's ongoing touch to help us. Through his embrace, his welcoming touch we can be enabled to realize that we are God's children, that we are loved despite our failings.
To be sure, we often fall short of God's intention in many ways. But God wills to give us new beginnings – to be loved and love, to be forgiven and forgive even as Christ loves and forgives us.
This dear people is GOOD NEWS! This is the heart of the Gospel that comes to us in the midst of any and all the experiences of our lives. May we live from the hope of being loved by God, whatever comes, for Christ's sake. Amen.