More Than A Big Whoop - Truth!
Reformation Sunday, October 26, 2014 (John 8:31-36; with Jeremiah 31:31-34 in b.g)
Then Jesus said to the Jews who had believed in him, or who were believing in him (depends on interpretation), "If you continue in my word, you are truly my disciples and you will know the truth and the truth will make you free."
Truth? ... Later Pontius Pilate asks Jesus at a critical time in their lives, "What is truth?" Yes, what is truth to us and for us?
Can we even "know" truth? Some post moderns say that there is no absolute or objective truth. Their claim is that our limited personal/cultural perspective prevents us from "knowing" larger truths, if there are any. They believe then that there are only little "truths". Our perspective of truth is determined by and large by where we live, our age and gender.
Truth then becomes an intellectual exercise, a philosophical quest. If such a perspective is accurate, well then truth is neither life-giving nor life altering.
But let me ask - if that is all "truth" is, do the deaths of Nathan Cirillo and Patrice Vincent matter only to their friends and families, to patriotic Canadians and perhaps thousands of others who have compassionate or sentimental hearts? Or, is there something more, much more here in the deaths of these two men? Is there an objective truth that matters to all of us – to how we will live and die? How will Nathan's five year old son live without his dad? Will he grow up to be mistrusting, bitter? How will Patrice's twin sister live without her brother? Will she be dominated by hatred?
And how will we as a country respond to such violence? Will we graffiti mosques, make judgment on Muslims, even though few of us know many if any of those people? How will we, how are we treating or responding to people who are lonely, estranged from their families, who start down a violent path when they are quite young?
I don't know about you but I found myself all over the map emotionally on Wednesday. The horror of a man doing his job, being shot point blank by one he didn't even know is ... tragic. I prayed that the person or person(s) shooting wouldn't kill anyone else. I also am ashamed to admit but there is a part of me, that wanted the police, the military, to not just capture the shooter but punish him. Those feelings came to the surface as I watched events unfold.
What do we do with that part of us that so easily irrupts with fear and self-righteous anger, boiling over with hatred, blame? What do with feelings even an underlying belief that if we can just somehow eradicate a violent person, or an group of people that "things" will somehow automatically be better or alright?
Can violence be redemptive? Will killing Michael Zehaf-Bibeau who killed Nathan Cirillo make us safe or even safer, or even somehow "free"? ... Or is there a profound truth here?
Today we Lutheran Christians celebrate the Reformation. We remember that 498 years ago Martin Luther nailed 95 theses on the doors of the Castle Church in Wittenberg. So what? Some might say "big whoop". What does that have to do with me, with us? If all that the 95 theses pointed to were "problems, corruption of the Church in that time and place, well then I might agree. Big whoop! For sure, there were things that needed change then. And there was change.
But our problems, our struggles continue. Lutherans and Roman Catholics have at times hated each other. We Lutherans have often been convinced that we are right and that "they" are wrong. Roman Catholics have often been convinced that they are right and we are wrong. From such thinking, such conviction we have wounded, insulted, injured and even killed each other. None of this is appropriate behavior for Christians! We need attitude adjustments that arise from transformed hearts - the very center of our beings, individually and collectively. We need to be changed and changing in our relationships with each other. And there has been some change in this regard. Thanks be to God!
Which gets to the point. For such change to occur we need help beyond ourselves. It matters not if it's the Hadfield and McCoys or blacks and whites, aboriginals and those of us who came to this land much later. We as human beings, creatures of the earth, need help beyond ourselves to change so that we do not hate, blame, do violence to ourselves, others and the very creation God gifts us with. I am convinced that this reality is truth beyond my limited perspective. Regardless of any historian's bias – the murdering, plundering, hatred and genocide has been going on for time immemorial. WE MUST SEE AND KNOW THIS, about ourselves.
But even that isn't' the whole truth! There is another way for life. It is not a way of ease or pretense. It is a wonderful, miraculous way.
This is the way of God's Son, Jesus. This is the way of God's liberating love for all people. Please notice that I say people: not people who have been reduced to stereotypes which are betrayed by generalized names like tax collectors, or presently experts or bums or call girls or any number of ethnically pejorative names that we know too well. We need to remember that when we refer to people, that they are real, flesh and blood people. Every individual, and the whole world, the cosmos, is to embraced with the love of God. In Jesus calls us to reflect this love, to in particular ways flesh out this embrace. Jesus loved not in word alone or only when things were good for him. Jesus also loved during the most difficult times in his life, when the personal cost was the greatest.
Jesus loved not by denying reality or forgetting about the people who were intentionally doing him wrong. Jesus loved not by seeking vengeance but by affording these same people additional opportunities to try again. Even as Jesus hangs dying on a cross, he cries out to God to forgive those who are executing him.
This is not what you or I would normally or naturally do. Not by a long shot! But this is Jesus' way. He refuses to pretend that everything is OK, even with himself. He also refuses to cast blame on others in order to get rid of them pretending that violence of any kind will "fix" things.
Acting in obedience to God His Father, Jesus opens us to another way. Jesus allows hatred, violence and death to have their way with him, but refuses to return in kind. Somehow, as only God's work can be fleshed out, Jesus turns hatred, violence, blame and death into loving acceptance, peace, reconciliation and new life.
This is life with God. Such life is a gift that flows from the life, death and resurrection, the abiding love of Jesus, God's own Son. Such life involves a kind of dying and being reborn each day. There is dying to old attitudes, fear, hatred and blame. There is being reborn to new possibilities, hope in the midst of struggle and pain. There is the response of a joyful giving of oneself to God. Without such "dying" and "rising" individually and collectively we remain stuck in ongoing cycles of violence, hatred, fear and blame.
So it is. We need to hear the stories of Jesus and ourselves again and again. We need to see Jesus' cross to behold truth, truth beyond ourselves but also truth that cuts to the heart. There are incredibly powerful forces that regularly seek to claim and bind our minds and hearts. We need to see the cross of Christ so that we do not live in denial of our own heart sickness. And we need to hear the words of Christ, the promises of Christ again and again, so that we are reclaimed and continually empowered to love and forgive, even as we are being loved and forgiven.
Make no mistake -the power of evil is real. But it's not just in Michael Zehaf- Bibeau or in the people of ISIS. This power of evil will not disappear should the efforts to execute or blame certain others whom we experience as doing evil.
The power of evil is only now stayed and ultimately overcome as God puts it to death within and among ourselves and raises something new, something of God within and through us. This is the way of Jesus which can never be earned but is freely given to us and offered to all by God.
This, dear people, is truth arising beyond us, begging to be lived with by us – wonderful, miraculous amazing. Isn't living in this way, incredible freedom – where fear, hatred and death die, where reconciliation, new life and love abound! To such freedom – the freedom of God, where all can be free. Amen.